Stub ticket · 29 September 1954
Willie Mays Makes "The Catch"
Stub · 29 September 1954 · PSA 130 · 52 sales
Highest ever
$29,280
Authentic, 31 Dec 2023, Goldin
Most recent sale
$7,625
PSA 5, 23 Aug 2026, Heritage
also low, last 3 months
High, last 3 months
$9,150
PSA 5, 11 Jul 2026, Heritage
Every recorded sale (52)
| Sold | Grade | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|
 23 Aug 2026Heritage | PSA 5latest | Heritage | $8k$7,625 |
 11 Jul 2026Heritage | PSA 5 | Heritage | $9k$9,150 |
| 21 Dec 2025Heritage | PSA 3 | Heritage | $5k$5,002 |
 15 Nov 2025Lelands | PSA 2 | Lelands | $4k$3,599 |
 1 Nov 2025Rea | PSA 4 | Rea | $10k$10,455 |
 8 Jul 2025Ebay | PSA 4 | Ebay | $7k$6,659 |
 26 May 2025Ebay | PSA 1 | Ebay | $2k$2,076 |
 18 May 2025Heritage | PSA 4 | Heritage | $6k$6,100 |
 27 Apr 2025Goldin | PSA 1.5 | Goldin | $2k$2,013 |
 19 Jan 2025Ebay | PSA 1 | Ebay | $6k$6,000 |
 7 Dec 2024Heritage | Authentic | Heritage | $1k$1,320 |
 27 Oct 2024Goldin | Authentic | Goldin | $2k$2,318 |
| 6 Oct 2024Heritage | PSA 3 | Heritage | $2k$1,680 |
 25 Aug 2024Heritage | PSA 1.5 | Heritage | $2k$1,860 |
 6 Jun 2024Cleansweep | PSA 2 | Cleansweep | $982$982 |
| 29 Apr 2024Ebay | Authentic | Ebay | $1k$1,403 |
 16 Mar 2024Lelands | PSA 1.5 | Lelands | $3k$2,950 |
 1 Feb 2024Rea | PSA 1.5 | Rea | $3k$2,640 |
 31 Dec 2023Goldin | Authenticrecord | Goldin | $29k$29,280 |
 20 Nov 2023Ebay | Authentic | Ebay | $2k$1,650 |
 18 Nov 2023Lelands | PSA 2 | Lelands | $3k$2,926 |
 1 Nov 2023Rea | PSA 4 | Rea | $3k$2,880 |
 1 Sept 2023Rea | Authentic | Rea | $3k$2,640 |
| 11 Jun 2023Ebay | PSA 1.5 | Ebay | $6k$6,000 |
 18 May 2023Goldin | PSA 1.5 | Goldin | $2k$2,280 |
| 15 May 2023Lelands | PSA 4 | Lelands | $8k$7,878 |
| 13 May 2023Heritage | Authentic | Heritage | $2k$1,860 |
| 13 May 2023Heritage | PSA 1 | Heritage | $5k$4,680 |
 17 Mar 2023Ebay | PSA 2 | Ebay | $3k$3,061 |
| 26 Feb 2023Heritage | Authentic | Heritage | $4k$3,840 |
 26 Feb 2023Heritage | PSA 1 | Heritage | $4k$3,720 |
 9 Feb 2023Goldin | PSA 2 | Goldin | $3k$3,300 |
 2 Feb 2023Cleansweep | PSA 1.5 | Cleansweep | $3k$2,963 |
 15 Aug 2022Lelands | PSA 3 | Lelands | $3k$3,037 |
| 10 Jun 2022Cleansweep | PSA 1.5 | Cleansweep | $3k$3,120 |
| 23 Jan 2022Heritage | PSA 1 | Heritage | $3k$3,480 |
 10 Jan 2022Goldin | PSA 1.5 | Goldin | $7k$7,200 |
 10 Jan 2022Goldin | PSA 1 | Goldin | $7k$6,900 |
 12 Feb 2021Ebay | PSA 4 | Ebay | $4k$4,170 |
| 1 Feb 2021Ebay | PSA 4 | Ebay | $2k$2,450 |
| 14 Jan 2021Ebay | PSA 4 | Ebay | $2k$2,425 |
| 8 Apr 2020Ebay | PSA 2 | Ebay | $725$725 |
 15 Nov 2019Lelands | Authentic | Lelands | $362$362 |
| 18 Aug 2019Ebay | PSA 1 | Ebay | $640$640 |
| 2 Aug 2019Ebay | PSA 3 | Ebay | $1k$1,200 |
| 28 Mar 2019Ebay | Authentic | Ebay | $265$265 |
| 27 Mar 2019Fanatics | Authentic | Fanatics | $265$265 |
| 14 Mar 2019Ebay | Authentic | Ebay | $450$450 |
| 27 Nov 2018Ebay | PSA 2 | Ebay | $495$495 |
| 21 Nov 2018Ebay | Authentic | Ebay | $510$510 |
 14 Aug 2016Goldin | Authentic | Goldin | $900$900 |
 1 Apr 2014Hugginsscott | Authentic | Hugginsscott | $474$474 |
Newest first. Prices are realised public auction results including buyer's premium.
What it makes at each grade
| Grade | Pop | Sales | Sold range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Authentic | 33 | 15 | $265-$29k$265 to $29,280 |
| PSA 1 | 16 | 7 | $640-$7k$640 to $6,900 |
| PSA 1.5 | 18 | 9 | $2k-$7k$1,860 to $7,200 |
| PSA 2 | 22 | 7 | $495-$4k$495 to $3,599 |
| PSA 3 | 17 | 4 | $1k-$5k$1,200 to $5,002 |
| PSA 4 | 14 | 8 | $2k-$10k$2,425 to $10,455 |
| PSA 5 | 3 | 2 | $8k-$9k$7,625 to $9,150 |
Grades are read from PSA's own record for each certificate, not from the auction title. Population is PSA's latest census, which can trail a recent grading.
Ungraded, it is worth a fraction of this.
This stub makes $265 at the bottom of the grade scale and $29,280 at PSA 5. Grading is the single biggest lever on what yours is worth.
See what grading yours could add