Stub ticket · 1 October 1919

Cicotte Hits 1st Batter-Rain Check (Game 1 @ Redland Field)

Stub · 1 October 1919 · PSA 35 · 18 sales

Reds-9.White Sox-1 Oct.1 · PSA has graded 35 · 18 public sales

Highest ever

$32,400

PSA 1.5, 28 Aug 2022, Heritage

Most recent sale

$30,643

PSA 2, 23 Aug 2026, Heritage

also only sale, last 3 months

Every recorded sale (18)

Sold	Grade	Where	Price
23 Aug 2026Heritage	PSA 2latest	Heritage	$31k$30,643
31 Jan 2026Heritage	PSA 3	Heritage	$31k$30,500
26 Oct 2025Heritage	PSA 2	Heritage	$17k$17,080
24 Aug 2025Heritage	PSA 1.5	Heritage	$15k$15,250
25 Feb 2024Heritage	Authentic	Heritage	$8k$8,100
30 Sept 2023Heritage	PSA 1.5	Heritage	$14k$13,800
13 May 2023Heritage	PSA 2	Heritage	$19k$18,600
1 Apr 2023Rea	Authentic	Rea	$6k$6,300
19 Nov 2022Heritage	Authentic	Heritage	$8k$8,400
19 Nov 2022Heritage	PSA 2	Heritage	$11k$10,500
28 Aug 2022Heritage	PSA 1.5record	Heritage	$32k$32,400
14 May 2022Heritage	PSA 2	Heritage	$17k$16,800
1 Nov 2021Rea	Authentic	Rea	$7k$7,200
7 Apr 2021Goldin	Authentic	Goldin	$10k$10,200
13 Dec 2020Heritage	Authentic	Heritage	$3k$3,000
1 Nov 2019Rea	Authentic	Rea	$2k$2,400
3 Jan 2019Ebay	PSA 2	Ebay	$2k$1,700
9 Aug 2015Goldin	Authentic	Goldin	$4k$3,600

Newest first. Prices are realised public auction results including buyer's premium.

What it makes at each grade

Grade	Pop	Sales	Sold range
Authentic	12	8	$2k-$10k$2,400 to $10,200
PSA 1	6	-	-
PSA 1.5	4	3	$14k-$32k$13,800 to $32,400
PSA 2	6	6	$2k-$31k$1,700 to $30,643
PSA 3	4	1	$31k$30,500
PSA 6	1	-	-

Grades are read from PSA's own record for each certificate, not from the auction title. Population is PSA's latest census, which can trail a recent grading.

Ungraded, it is worth a fraction of this.

This stub makes $2,400 at the bottom of the grade scale and $32,400 at PSA 3. Grading is the single biggest lever on what yours is worth.

See what grading yours could add